Plaster vs Tile Pool Finishes for Your Concrete Pool: Which Lasts Longer?
Choosing the right finish for your pool can feel like a big decision. After all, it's going to significantly impact your pool's aesthetics and maintenance for years to come. Traditionally, plaster pool finishes and aggregate finishes have been the widespread standard due to cost and easier installation. However, there’s an even better option: All tile pools.
When considering plaster vs tile pool finishes, there are practical factors to think about beyond just how it looks and bragging rights. In this article, we’ll break down those factors and help you see why tile finishes, while a bigger upfront investment, win in the long run.
It's important to have a clear idea of your priorities. What matters most to you: initial cost, longevity, visual appeal, or ease of maintenance? Your answer to this question will greatly influence which option is best for you. Let’s dive into some pool finish options.
Table Of Contents:
- Plaster Pool Finishes: The Budget-Friendly Original
- All Tile Pool Finishes: The Pinnacle of Durability and Design
- Installation Tips and Important Info for Your Pool Project
- Conclusion
Plaster Pool Finishes: The Budget-Friendly Original
Plaster has been the go-to choice for decades, thanks to its affordability. Compared to other pool finishes, a simple plaster pool finish will be the least expensive option. Plaster gives a classic, smooth look to the pool. It’s also available in a variety of colors from white, blue, and even dark gray for a grotto look.
But, like most budget-friendly options, a plaster pool comes with compromises. It tends to be more porous than other surfaces. This means it's prone to staining, algae growth, and general wear and tear, requiring frequent maintenance. You'll be looking at weekly scrubbing, plus an acid wash every few years to keep it looking its best. Even with diligent care, plaster pool finishes tend to last between 7-10 years on average.
Aggregate pool finishes offer a superior alternative to traditional plaster finishes. By incorporating quartz, stone, or even glass beads into the plaster base, these finishes provide enhanced durability, resistance to abrasion, staining, and chemical damage. This results in a longer lifespan and reduced maintenance requirements compared to smooth plaster.
The textured surfaces, created by mixing pebbles, quartz, glass beads, or other materials into the plaster, not only add visual appeal but also contribute to the overall durability of the finish. Aggregate pool finishes typically last between 10 to 15 years on average, making them a worthwhile investment for homeowners seeking a long-lasting and aesthetically pleasing pool surface.
Plaster with Stone or Quartz Aggregate
Plaster with stone or quartz aggregates are generally the more affordable upgrade to a plaster finish that adds texture and visual interest to your pool. The aggregate particles can range from small to large, creating a variety of looks. These finishes are generally more durable and resistant to staining than plain plaster however, it can be more difficult to maintain.
Plaster with Glass Aggregate
Plaster with glass aggregate offers a unique, upscale look compared to stone or quartz aggregates for an additional cost. The glass particles create a shimmering effect in the water, adding a touch of elegance to your pool. This type of finish is also more durable and resistant to staining compared to its counterparts but may require special maintenance to keep the glass particles looking good.
According to the experts at ASP (America’s Swimming Pool Co.) one consideration with glass bead aggregate finishes is that some pool owners have noticed fading or discoloration over time. Although manufacturers may have improved their products' fade resistance since the issue was first reported, all plaster surfaces require eventual refinishing.
All Tile Pool Finishes: The Pinnacle of Durability and Design
For the ultimate pool finish, consider an all-glass or porcelain tile pool. While tile may be a more expensive option upfront, its long-term benefits easily outweigh the initial investment.
Glass pool tile is renowned for its durability, longevity, and stunning beauty. When installed correctly, it's the most durable, long-lasting, and visually appealing pool surface available. Beyond its durability, glass tile offers incredible versatility, allowing you to create a truly unique and personalized pool design. It’s no wonder it’s the most common and sought-after tile finish!
Glass tiles have dramatically gained popularity over the years because of their unique capability to bounce and reflect light through their unmatched iridescence. It is also the perfect material for pool and submerged applications because of its non-porous and waterproof characteristics. If finishing your entire pool in glass tile isn’t in your plans, consider using it for your pool’s waterline. Let's look at all the benefits of glass:
Unmatched Durability
Glass pool tile finishes are the most durable pool finish. On average, they last much longer than plaster finishes while requiring less upkeep. When properly installed using high-quality installation materials such as Litokol Litoelastic tile adhesive and Starlike EVO epoxy grout, tile can last indefinitely, making it a wise investment in the long run. Tile is the longest-lasting pool shell finish.
Endless Design Possibilities
Say goodbye to bland, single-color pools. Glass tile opens up a world of possibilities for custom designs and visual appeal. They come in a huge variety of colors, textures, and finishes. You can achieve intricate mosaics, vibrant color palettes, and even natural stone looks - the design options are limitless.
There are also many custom design options when finishing your pool with tile. From custom gradients and color blends to intricate mosaic art installations, we can create anything you can dream up for a truly one-of-a-kind personalized design.
Ease of Cleaning
Glass tile isn't porous like plaster, so it resists staining. The smooth finish also deters algae buildup. A regular brush-down is all it takes to keep the surface clean. This makes a tile pool much easier to maintain compared to plaster. It doesn’t need an acid wash every few years which saves on chemicals, time, and effort in the long run.
Additional Benefits of Glass Tile
When choosing between plaster vs tile pool finishes, glass tile stands out even further with some specific advantages. First, it’s incredibly durable and resistant to chemicals, UV rays, and even frost. It will look brand new for years with minimal effort.
It also has an inherent shimmer that enhances a pool’s aesthetics. The way light plays off a glass tile surface adds a touch of luxury and brilliance. It’s important to choose an experienced and qualified tile installer for the best outcome with glass tile, as improper installation can result in sharp edges and potential installation failure.
For a deeper dive into the specifications of a top-notch glass tile installation, take a look at this resource guide. Here’s what it comes down to; while tile costs more initially, it offers significant benefits that make it a superior option in the long run. Consider these key differences when choosing between concrete vs tile pool finishes:
| Feature | Tile | Plaster + Aggregate | Plaster |
|---|---|---|---|
| Durability | Extremely Durable - potential lifespan of 20+ years | Less durable compared to tile, but more durable than plain plaster - potential lifespan of 10-15 years | Lease durable - lifespan of 7-10 years |
| Design Options | Unlimited design possibilities due to colors, textures, and material combinations + custom designs and color blends | More design options than plain plaster - materials include stone, quartz, or glass | Limited Design options. Often plain, white, blue, or gray |
| Maintenance | Easy to clean with simple brushing and wipe-down | May require special treatments depending on the material type | Requires regular scrubbing and chemical treatments to control staining and algae growth |
| Initial Cost | Most expensive | The mid-range cost option. | Most Affordable option |
Installation Tips and Important Info for Your Pool Project
Building a new pool or renovating an existing one is certainly an exciting time. However, there are a few key factors that are often overlooked. Here are some informative nuggets to be aware of when selecting your pool finish that will not only help you achieve your aesthetic goals but also help ensure a successful installation!
Add a Pool Mosaic for Extra Pizzaz
To enhance a plaster finish, homeowners often incorporate decorative pool mosaics. Pool mosaics add some character and charm to any plaster pool surface ranging from playful dolphins, turtles and rays to more modernized scrolls and medallions. They look stunning against a plaster background.
Protect Your Tiles by Waterproofing
Protect your beautiful tiles from unsightly efflorescence. Waterproofing provides a protective layer between your pool shell and your tile. By applying a waterproofing membrane to the tiled areas in your pool, you ensure a watertight seal that prevents water damage and unsightly build-up. Apply a layer of Basecrete waterproofing bondcoat or Litokol’s Aquamaster to your pool shell before installing tiles. This added protection gives you peace of mind and extends the lifespan and beauty of your pool.
Choose the Best Grout for Your Tile: Starlike EVO Epoxy Grout
Starlike EVO epoxy grout is the ultimate choice for protecting your tile investment. Imported from Italy, this high-performance grout is resistant to stains, chemicals, and scratches, ensuring your tile remains pristine for years to come. With a vast range of colors and add-ins available, you can easily match your grout to your tile and aesthetic.
Prepare the Substrate for a Flawless Installation
Ensure the substrate is level, clean, and dry before installing tiles. Any imperfections or moisture issues can lead to costly repairs or even tile failure. Take the time to properly prepare the surface to guarantee a successful installation.
Hire a Skilled Tile Installer for a Professional Finish
While it may be tempting to DIY, a professional tile installer can make all the difference in the final result. They possess the expertise and experience to ensure a flawless installation, handle complex tile layouts, and troubleshoot any potential issues that may arise.
By following these expert tips, you'll be able to enjoy a stunning, durable, and low-maintenance pool area that's perfect for outdoor entertaining and relaxation.
Conclusion
When weighing the options of plaster vs tile pool finishes, tile emerges as a clear winner for long-term value, durability, and design possibilities. This is despite the higher upfront costs. If the budget allows, it's a worthwhile investment to enjoy years of low maintenance and a stunning pool you can truly take pride in.
For help finding the perfect tile for your pool, give us a call at (800) 971-1442 and Bring Paradise Home today.
